States Lag in Educating Students About Personal Finance

By: - March 4, 2014 12:00 am

Students at Calera High School in Alabama surround New Orleans Saints running back Mark Ingram, center left, and Alabama Treasurer Young Boozer after playing an online game of Financial Football that teaches financial literacy. Alabama recently began requiring that high school students take a personal finance course. (Courtesy Office of Alabama State Treasurer)

Students paid attention when Mark Ingram, former Alabama Crimson Tide star and current running back for the New Orleans Saints, showed up at Calera High School outside of Birmingham.

Ingram and Alabama state Treasurer Young Boozer unveiled a free educational videogame called Financial Football, developed by the NFL and Visa, Inc. The game allows students to move their favorite team down the field and score if they answer money management questions correctly. Now in 41 states, the game and classroom curriculum aim to give high school and middle school students the fundamentals of personal finance.

“Students enjoyed the game,” said Dawn Morrison of the Alabama Department of Education. “They did learn something without realizing they were learning.”

The recent recession raised greater awareness of the importance of money management skills as many people purchased homes they could not afford by signing mortgages they did not fully understand. But the recession also cut deeply into state budgets, forcing policymakers to find new ways to get money management into school curriculums and creative ways to pay for it (see sidebar).

Currently, only four states — Missouri, Tennessee, Utah and Virginia — require that high school students take a stand-alone personal finance course to graduate, according to Jump Coalition, made up of 150 financial institutions, consumer groups and federal agencies.

The Council of Economic Education, which also gets backing from businesses and financial institutions estimates that 17 states require high school students to take courses that include personal finance instruction. Both groups lobby for more financial literacy in schools.

Teens are big consumers, as much as $91 billion in 2011, by one estimate, but few are saving for college or other long-term goals or understand basic financial terms. More than 75 percent of 16- to 18-year-olds say they are financially savvy, but less than 20 percent knew what a 401(k) plan is and only 32 percent knew how credit card interest and fees work, according to a 2011 survey from the investment firm of Charles Schwab & Co.  Less than a third of young adults had basic knowledge of interest rates, inflation and other financial terms, according to a federal study.

Ways to Fund Financial Literacy

New State Requirements

In some states, such as Alabama, personal finance is taught as part of another course. Alabama has been on the bottom of many state-by-state rankings for personal finance instruction, and a state-appointed commission had recommended better courses for high school students.

Beginning this year, students there will have to pass a course called Career Preparedness to graduate, under new state Department of Education requirements. The course includes financial literacy, but also teaches basic computer programs, such as Word and Excel, needed in the workplace.

Advocates are pressing schools to incorporate personal finance in math and language arts classes in elementary schools. “You’ve got to start early,” said Laura Levine, executive director of Jump Coalition. “A one-semester course should not be the end-all.”

Nearly 20 states last year approved legislation or adopted resolutions regarding financial literacy, according to a tally by the National Conference of State Legislatures.  Among them, California required the state board of education to integrate financial literacy into existing curriculums. 

Florida revised requirements for high school graduation to include financial literacy within a required economics course, and Maine added personal finance course work as part of social studies or history courses that are required for graduation. Utah established a task force to look at how to improve financial and economic literacy education in the public school system.

States and schools can tap into various federal grant programs, including from the Department of Education, for financial literacy, and federal websites and toolkits. But many schools also are finding help from companies with a vested interest, such as Visa and others in the financial sector.

Private Industry Help

Visa’s Practical Money Skills program that developed Financial Football with the NFL is among the most high profile privately produced financial literacy programs offered to states and schools. A YouTube video released this year, for example, stars San Francisco 49ers players Joe Staley and Colt McCoy as well as California State Controller John Chiang and California State Board of Equalization member Betty T. Yee. The games also are available as a free app for use on personal electronic devices.

Other organizations that provide schools free financial literacy help are:

  • PricewaterhouseCoopers has pledged $60 million to improve financial literacy, including partnering with Knowledge@Wharton High School to roll out a series of teacher training seminars and developing a set of 18 ready-to-use free modules for grades 3-12.
  • Discover Financial Services has promised to provide $10 million in grants to high schools to cover the cost of implementing a financial education curriculum.
  • Nonprofits, such as the Council for Economic Education, provide lesson plans and their own online games.  A website called Money as You Learn offers educators tools to integrate personal finance into the teaching and has won the endorsement of several education groups.
  • Children’s financial literacy programs also got a boost from PNC Financial Services Group which is giving $12 million and videos that feature Elmo and Cookie Monster from “Sesame Street.”
  • 82 colleges including the Indiana University system, are using an online financial education course from EverFi, a technology company that uses video, animations, 3-D gaming, avatars and social networking to explain financial concepts to today’s digital generation.

Not everyone thinks more financial literacy courses in schools will result in financially savvy consumers, including Loyola Law School professor Lauren Willis. “Financial literacy classes give people the illusion that they can successfully manage their finances,” she has said. “So rather than seek help, they end up making worse decisions.” She contends that parents, not the government, do better job teaching children on day-to-day spending. The government should focus more making sure financial products are safe.

Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.